Showing posts with label Intervention. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Intervention. Show all posts

Thursday, August 30, 2018

Organizational Development Article: Intervention Round Up-Sensitivity Training

During an Organizational Development class, it was asked about our take on models that seeks to engage stakeholders within a corporate environment and during the class we needed to interact via an online discussion. Every once in a while, we have to pose questions to one another, in this post I have posted the question and my response to that question. I hope the interactions below assist in research, or even understanding the concepts of the different models that engage stakeholders in a positive manner and what from some academic sense future practitioners think of these concepts and the arenas it can be used in.

Sensitivity Training is one of those interventions that is great (like my choice 360 Feedback) if properly used and everyone bought into the use of the intervention. However, I can see it be used in a negative connation to gauge where employees stand on certain organizational issues, or how employees feel about the current structure and policies of an organization only to have management use that information against the employee. In my experience when management asks “how do you feel...” about a certain issue, the current direction of or the leadership in the organization, they are usually mining for data to find the” trouble makers” in a department and make their time with the organization uncomfortable as possible.

With a lot of this depending on the emotional intelligence and egos of those participating how would you ensure that when this intervention is used, that participants do not act negatively in and out of group sessions?  How would you ensure that the original focus of this intervention stays on point for future usage after the OD Practitioner is gone?

http://www.citeman.com/979-sensitivity-training.html

Tuesday, August 28, 2018

Organizational Development Article: Intervention Round Up-Mentoring

During an Organizational Development class, it was asked about our take on models that seeks to engage stakeholders within a corporate environment and during the class we needed to interact via an online discussion. Every once in a while, we have to pose questions to one another, in this post I have posted the question and my response to that question. I hope the interactions below assist in research, or even understanding the concepts of the different models that engage stakeholders in a positive manner and what from some academic sense future practitioners think of these concepts and the arenas it can be used in.

Mentoring is an interesting intervention because much like other intervention like 360 Feedback (my choice) it can be used in a positive manner or with a negative connation for corrective action purposes. Through my professional experiences I have had great mentors and terrible ones, usually the latter I had to deal with supervisors or management that were busy trying to teach me how to disregard procedures to complete activities in order to raise overall productivity percentages.

However, it made them look good to upper management, this type of mentoring caused issues with the task completion when the completed activities were quality checked or needed to be replicated.
Keeping this in mind, in your experiences with mentoring have you encountered any ineffective mentors that simply stunted your professional development? Were there times in the mentoring process that you received duplicate training for two different individuals to the point it seemed repetitive?

Thursday, August 23, 2018

Organizational Development Article: Intervention Round Up-360 Feedback

During an Organizational Development class, it was asked about our take on models that seeks to engage stakeholders within a corporate environment and during the class we needed to interact via an online discussion. Every once in a while, we have to pose questions to one another, in this post I have posted the question and my response to that question. I hope the interactions below assist in research, or even understanding the concepts of the different models that engage stakeholders in a positive manner and what from some academic sense future practitioners think of these concepts and the arenas it can be used in.

Question: The 360 Feedback tool which I think is overused and overcommitted to as a tool to provide feedback. The problem often comes from misperceptions as to what 360 is and how it can be effectively used to advance employee effectiveness.
Not to take a reductionist stance, but in essence evaluation must have a clear and focused context and a process that is consistent and valuable for everyone, not just a supervisor. Also, consider the variance between a transformational 360 feedback session versus a transactional session.


Most of my experiences with 360 Feedback as a process comes from supervisors using the process as a corrective actions tool, emphasizing more of the negative aspects of my performance than including the feedback from myself or my peers.

Most of my coworkers and I would joke that it is called 360 Feedback because the process just runs the employee around in circles (360 degrees) without having any point to it. The only person who could make sense of this process was maybe the supervisor, who had an opportunity created by the one-way feedback session a scape goat.

Usually when I experienced or heard (from other employees) about this one-way feedback process, the purpose it seemed was to find the easiest person to blame for the team not meeting productivity goals. This process was filled, non- transformational sessions that caused more division and chaos than necessary and creates the misperception that the process is not for advancing employee effectiveness as you stated, but to punish.

I hope to be able to use resources such as my schoolwork, textbooks and the interactions with you and my fellow classmates to find ways to enlighten and teach organizational management in the future on the proper way to use the 360 Feedback process.

Tuesday, August 21, 2018

Organizational Development Article: Intervention Round Up

During an Organizational Development class, it was asked about our take on models that seeks to engage stakeholders within a corporate environment and during the class we needed to interact via an online discussion. Every once in a while, we have to pose questions to one another, in this post I have posted the question and my response to that question. I hope the interactions below assist in research, or even understanding the concepts of the different model that engage stakeholders in a positive manner and what from some academic sense future practitioners think of these concepts and the arenas it can be used in.

Question: I especially liked how you included self-concept or self-delusion of oneself. It is important to understand how we are viewed by others, especially if there are conflicts within a group/team/department. As you mentioned too often, I have too, 360-degree feedback is used incorrectly, and the focus is only on the negative versus the positive aspects. In this module, reading on 'Positive Organizational Scholarship and Appreciative Inquiry' it explains by focusing on the positive you can correct negative behavior without all the negative connotations.
Do you believe the 360 Degree Feedback can tied with POS or AI? Or that there would be benefits of realigning it so that it can be used more frequently as a way to improve an employee’s development?


Actually, I would use neither with the 360 Feedback. Unfortunately, it has been my experience that the individuals implementing the Feedback have no training whatsoever in the process and that is why it is done incorrectly, adding something extra to me is asking for more trouble.
For example, with Positive Organizational Scholarship (POS) I can see management telling the individual how to be motivated as it benefits the organization not the individual leading to all types of conflict. With Appreciative Inquiry, again I also see organizational management taking control of this process in a negative manner and telling the individual employee again what should motivate them also that it is beneficial to them (management) or the organization but not upon the professional development of the employee.

It has been my experience that many individuals in management have no idea about these concepts and would rather practice aspects of each that would benefit their agenda. I would hate to take the chance and subject employees with management that can add extra ways to torment their employees due to my additional training, even I would hate me! I would rather keep it simple with one concept (the 360 Feedback intervention) train the management on how to properly use it and monitor them excessively to make sure the entire concept is being practiced and the training of how to use the 360-feedback process is permanent.

Tuesday, July 3, 2018

Organizational Clarity: Human Performance Improvement -PDI Feedback

In another assignment in Human Performance Improvement class I was given the assignment to focus upon a creating change to a fictional organization (or part three) it focused upon the external stakeholders involved and how HPI can be used towards this group. Again, this is a fictional account with the details listed in an assignment and the parameters dealt with worst case scenario type issues in an organization so therefore with the idea of unlimited budgets and resources (I know when does that happens?) this assignment was crafted with those variables in mind. Please post any comments or questions to facilitate a discussion in the comments sections below.

Focusing on the Human Performance Technology (HPT) Model and building on the Cause Analysis mechanism, in the form of student surveys we build a foundation to gain an understanding of the environment factors which impact the team's and organization’s overall productivity. We also implement employee, management surveys to recreate the team spirit that is missing from the department. Therefore, using the HPT Model as the basis, we have selected five interventions for this project as defined in the Performance Support Tool 9.1:
  1. Personal Development Interventions (Feedback).
  2. Performance Support Interventions (Documentation and Standards)
  3. Organizational Design and Development Inventions (Empowerment-Team Strategies)
  4. Human Resource Development Interventions (Organization Growth-Management Development/Individual Growth-360-degree Appraisals).
  5. Organizational Design and Development (Organizational Values-Culture).
Of all the five interventions chosen, the number one intervention I deemed necessary to the success of this project is the Personal Development Interventions- Feedback. (Van Tiem, et al., 2012). This way team management The FA email team and site directors can discuss the issues of the Email backlog, low student survey score, lack of support, etc., in a collaborative manner. Done without fears of corrective action or further isolation occurring with the 360-degree feedback model (Hamilton, & Patel, 2012). This I feel is the easiest method to communicate solutions regarding the dysfunctional structure of procedures and processes that the organization’s customers are complaining about.  Since the organizational culture is embedded and the likelihood of a miraculous 360 change for the entire department or organization will not happen overnight.

I believe this is a more team oriented approach that allows all those concerned to gain an understanding how to improve their overall team performance and create an immediate but practical solution for productivity. This speedy intervention from an internal standpoint, allows immediate feedback and focus on the problem. From an external standpoint it immediately deals with issues that presently concern the student body. If we were to implement the other, protracted interventions first, the University would possibly face a major exodus of students as a result.

By administering a 360-degree survey the employees express their individual perceptions through the rating process of how the organization perceives them and their effectiveness in their job roles (Hazucha, et al,.1993). Included in that is how effective each individual perceives the impact of their coworkers and management staff this is all done anonymously so that the data is accurate as possible.

Coupled with the data gathered by the student surveys employees are then presented with all the material in a supportive atmosphere so that it facilitates effective coaching and development amongst the team members (Hamilton, & Patel, 2012). In this environment constructive feedback is shared between the employees and management staff so the performance responsibilities are clearly understood and the team’s performance can be improved. 360-degree feedback meetings and duplicate surveys are rescheduled for reinforcement purposes on a monthly basis are added to complement the original surveys and 360-degree meetings. This is done to judge the impact of the program upon the initial perceptions of the employees and what degree of change has occurred as a result.

Steps to administrating 360 Feedback Sessions
1.      Conduct Student Survey
2.      Gather Student Surveys
3.      Conduct Employee and Management Surveys
4.      Gather Employee and Management Surveys
5.      Tally all three surveys to rate the effectiveness of Management and Staff
6.      Constructive group feedback (through FA Jeopardy/team strategy meetings)
7.      Constructive individual feedback (through role playing/discussion of strengths and areas of development regarding performance)
8.      Monthly Follow up Surveys

My second choice was the Performance Support Intervention of Documentation and Standards, although I feel that employees need to be clear about the job requirements for their daily tasks, the Feedback intervention (360-degree feedback) would cover the basics of the intervention (Van Tiem, et al., 2012).  I would also add that the FA Email team overall customer service score on the student surveys was 63%, therefore one can concur the foundations for job expectations is already exists. Understanding why the performance gap happened and how to reach the desired performance in this situation could not be solved with just repeating current policies and procedures, to the employees.

Discussion for solutions for faulty procedures and policies as covered in the Feedback intervention would astern workable approaches to the enormous time sensitive problem that faces the team.
My third choice is the Organizational Design and Development Invention of Empowerment: Team Strategies again the basics of this intervention will be emphasized in the Feedback intervention (Van Tiem, et al., 2012). The problem here is that the FA email team is on an island by themselves, the organizational culture divides its departments into task oriented teams and by the type of Financial Aid knowledge needed to complete daily tasks. Included into the factors the strengthen this division are the competitive goals set by the organization which increases the negative effects that occur.

Stressing team exclusion is part of the organizational culture this problem is far-reaching to the point that there is a division between the FA email team and its management staff. The Beginning for the viable lines of communication with Feedback intervention starts the baby steps to becoming a true cohesive unit and meets the basic needs of all the stakeholders, now.

My fourth choice is Human Resource Development Interventions whether it is Organization Growth with Management Development or Individual Growth with 360-degree Appraisals the feedback approach is well and alive in both methods (Van Tiem, et al., 2012). In the 360-degree appraisals the customer surveys I have included in the Feedback intervention echoes here. However, there is no intent to “soften the blow” of the information given to the employee with the Organizational Culture that exists such an exercise would have a negative effect. This is due to the lack of knowledge that team management and FA site directors have of the expected job duties of the FA email team therefore without further information about these duties the ratings will be askew. The same holds true from the Management Development approach this is a lengthy approach that addresses the lack of interpersonal skills of the management staff, however due to time constraints training to bridge this lack of knowledge and personality is not suitable for this situation (Van Tiem, et al., 2012). The break between team management and the team itself is based on the lack of problem solving skills of management which this method adheres to solving. But an extensive needs assessment is required to fully understand that performance gap, something the organization is not willing to endure as the issues of low productivity numbers by the FA email team are affecting the rest or the organization.

To explain why my final choice is Organizational Design and Development, Organizational Values-Culture there is a realization that the Organizational culture is the initial cause for divisions in the department and the rest or the organization (Van Tiem, et al., 2012). This division is paralyzing the entire Organization to the point where simple restructuring of teams or the temporary assignment of employees to assist the FA email team is almost impossible. From a clinical and realistic standpoint, the organization needs to change entirely but not all of the stakeholders can wait for widespread modifications. As the survey data shows the student population is not elated with the University’s performance so far, and will not be patient. With any Organizational culture there is resistance to change for the organization to be successful in meeting the needs of its students it must have zero resistance to change. Therefore, the Feedback intervention is chosen to focus mainly upon the immediate team involved with this issue to get to the heart of the matter and work on creative solutions that address the issue at hand.
           
The best practices as demonstrated by the 360-degree feedback implementation at Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide, Inc. would be replicated here at Omir University (Caruso, 2011). For example, in the survey process, Starwood decided that their survey questions would be adjusted or aimed at the skill levels of management, not just the employees. Furthermore, this process addressed individual strengths along with areas that still needed development, through positive assessments and not the usual one on one coaching methods, that have considerable negative conations. This way everyone can add into this data their unique perceptions of how they contribute to the organization, what they do best and what they believe they need improvement with on a daily basis, without judgment.
           
As at Starwood, the 360-degree feedback implemented at Omir University would give the entire team a structure or foundation of “what to focus on” the team’s knowledge of individual expectations so that bridging any performance gaps will be simple (Caruso, 2011). From an organizational standpoint, the benefits gained from these best practices is a foundation of data to grow upon. Additionally, from this data, the University’s Human Resource department can develop additional programs with a distinct scope that reaches into each part of the department. This extended reach allows the University to reduce the waste of previous resources similar to the implementation at Starwood (Caruso, 2011).

References
Caruso, Karen N. (2011)“Case Study: Starwood Hotels Takes 360 Degree Feedback to a New Level” viaPeople Insight - Performance Management & Succession Planning Blog Mon, Aug 29, 2011 ViaPeople Retrieved on February 23, 2017 from: http://web.viapeople.com/viaPeople-blog/bid/65018/Case-Study-Starwood-Hotels-Takes-360-Degree-Feedback-to-a-New-Level

Hamilton, Diane, & Patel, Nilesh (2012) “Best practices in 360-degree feedback” Forward HR Aug 22, 2012 In Business Madison Retrieved on February 16, 2017 from: http://www.ibmadison.com/Blogger/Forward-HR/August-2012/Best-practices-in-360-degree-feedback/

Hazucha, J. F., Hezlett, S. A., & Schneider, R. J. (1993). The impact of 360‐degree feedback on management skills development. Human Resource Management, 32(2‐3), 325-351.

Van Tiem, D., Moseley, J. L., & Dessinger, J. C. (2012). Fundamentals of performance improvement: Optimizing results through people, process, and organizations. John Wiley & Sons.

Tuesday, June 26, 2018

Organizational Clarity: Human Performance Improvement -Pre-Project Situation Description

For one assignment in Human Performance Improvement class I was given the assignment to adjust and improve the workplace for a fictional organization while improving the environment for all the stakeholders involved. This is a fictional account with the variables listed in an assignment and the parameters dealt with worse case scenario type issues in an organization so therefore with the idea of unlimited budgets and resources (I know when does that happens?) this assignment was crafted with those variables in mind. Please post any comments or questions to facilitate a discussion in the comments sections below.

Pre-Project Situation Description
Purpose
Omir University is a multimillion dollar organization that is a for-profit institution which provides an online education to a host of students. In fact, the University prides itself on accepting individuals from all demographics and all walks of life. Their objective is providing students with a quality online education to help them succeed in their future careers. To belay scrutiny of its for-profit status in the educational field, Omir University as an accredited institution focuses upon a positive student experience to prove their claims of providing students with a quality education. This is done not only through the academic side but also the administrative side. The student experience determines the overall reputation of the University. Therefore, ensuring students are highly satisfied with all interactions (staff and/or management) are imperative.

To determine how well the various departments of Admissions, Financial Aid, and Academics performs, the students are asked to complete a brief survey after every phone call, email, and chat; each interaction even the lack thereof is given a percentage score by students. This determines the foundation of how Omir University determines their performance goals, not only on a quarterly basis but monthly as well.

Even with a student body of 35,000 students and sites nationwide, Omir University does have the ability to zero in with a laser focus on how to improve their quality scores. Omir University divides each department up separately and then breaks down the scores by the teams assigned to each communication method or queue. The passing grade for all departments in these three various methods of communication (phone, email, and chat) is at 90%.

Statement of the Need or Opportunity
Every department and team have a 90% passing grade from the student reviews, except the Financial Aid email team. Their scores are significantly lower because student surveys state they have emailed Financial aid and after brief interactions, have not received any additional responses to resolve their issue.

In some cases, students stated they have not received responses to initial inquiries at all. In either instance, this results in a failing grade for the Financial Aid email team, bringing down their overall scores for the month and quarter to 63%. As a result, these students have also increased the communication “traffic” of the other three major departments I have aforementioned. This increase in traffic gives the students what they believe is the “runaround” and in turn decreases the customer service scores of these other teams and departments. The Financial Aid email team’s backlog is basically affecting the organization and is causing students (who are their customers) to seek educational opportunities elsewhere.

Work Environment
The Work Environment in regards to customer service (the focus of the intervention) is segmented into three departments (Admissions, Financial Aid, and Academics).  It is then divided further with the way information is communicated to the student (phone, online chat, and email).
The entire Financial Aid Email team is in Omir University’s Chicago downtown location; resources needed will be limited. All training sessions can be held in the sixth-floor conference room without additional set up.

The University rents three floors of the office building and the Financial Aid Email team is situated upon the fifth floor segmented from the rest of the Financial Aid team (which is on the sixth floor); this allows assignment of training sessions easier to accomplish.
The team is responsible for all the University’s communication with students regarding their Financial Aid inquiries there are presently no backup systems or procedures in place. The team seating arrangement has a basic six “block” cubical arraignment which physically adds to the “bubble” effect or segregation that the team has developed (from the rest of the department and organization).

The competition between departments and the teams that they are divided into, within the organization is very competitive. Therefore, getting support or creating additional avenues to “attack” the email backlog and improve customer service scores for the team and the organization is also a significant challenge. The result of these office politics has made the employees of the email team embroiled or committed to old procedures and policies and creates as a byproduct, the current 63% customer service approval rating. Additionally, any “outside” help or procedural mandates either from other parts of the Financial Aid department (onsite management) or outside of the organization is met with skepticism.

Target Audience
The target audience consists of:
  • The Financial Aid email team,
  • Financial Aid Managers,
  • Financial Aid team leads,
  • Associate Financial Aid (onsite) director, and the
  • Financial Aid (onsite) director.
These individuals are the main and direct focus of the HPI intervention as the entire organization is affected by the scores (of the Financial Aid email team).

Resources required
Resources for this intervention are:
  • One conference room that seats ten to thirteen individuals for two days,
  • Thirteen laptops with online access,
  • One overhead projector,
  • One hundred active emails/files for training purposes,
  • Paper (printed) handouts,
  • Five boxes of pens, and
  • Thirteen notepads.
The groups will be divided into shifts as the entire ten-person team cannot be scheduled for the training sessions all at one time. Therefore, only half of the team will be scheduled between 8 am to 12 pm (half day sessions). Limited supplies and space to conduct training sessions will be used to keep costs down and maximize ROI. The entire cost will be minimal as the materials needed are already onsite and available for usage by the entire team, management staff, and consultant.

Sponsor(s)
The sponsors are:
  • Financial Aid director,
  • Vice President of Financial Aid, and
  • HPI4TC consultant Martin Prosser.
Having the management team involved as well as the onsite directors will ensure a better understanding (and the seriousness) of these changes and the training sessions. This will also help in fostering an inclusive team atmosphere between these once-divided groups. By including onsite management will also help these individuals properly understand daily operations and the step by step methodology of daily task completion from the email team’s point of view. This way any future changes to performance-based procedures and policies will be based upon realistic expectations of processes that can be truly achieved.  This will also reassure the team that management is fully committed and involved in their processes and professional development.

Performance Improvement Goal
As previously stated the Performance goal that the Financial Aid email team must reach is a 90% approval rating on the surveys given to students after every interaction with the team.
The email backlog is tallied to be at least 5,000 emails. It is unrealistic to complete and respond to these emails within a months’ time. Figuring in that each team member will need to complete only 25 of these emails daily for a month to catch up, there are still an influx of email communications coming in daily (at least 75 emails per day). Plus, there are about 1,000 emails that are simply lost or not responded to bringing down the team’s performance scores even more.

As the team is inconsistent the goals are to have each team member complete at least 30 email responses per day, (completing most of the backlog before the end of the month by at least 75%). The training sessions will be covering new procedures and new email templates to maximize the time spent on each email response and cover the amount of detail needed to satisfy each student.
Management will assist the email team with “weeding out” additional or multiple responses (i.e.: email chains) from the same student regarding the same issue that was previously responded to beforehand (an “additional email elimination” process). For example, if a student has previously contacted a Financial email representative regarding the date of their stipend and this question has been answered, only to have the student respond with a “thanks” the lack of response by the representative was usually counted as a “missing” response and counted against the team.

Now, with the new procedures after the initial conclusion of that interaction that “missing” response will not be factored into the representative and team’s overall customer service score as a “non-response”. By weeding out emails that do not need additional responses we believe we will reduce the backlog by at least 178-200 emails increasing the possibility of successful implementation of this program. With this Performance improvement goal in place, it is projected to bring the scores above the 90% requirement.

Measures of Success
  • We are projecting that the Financial Aid email team will reach a customer service approval percentage score of the 90% or better by the next month and by the next quarterly report. This will alleviate the issues that affect the organization and improve relations within the Financial Aid department and organization with the immediate turnaround.
  • The introduction of new streamlined processes and new email templates will cut down on the time and resources expended by each team member per response. But, increase productivity to meet the required daily email completion quota, that will reduce the email backlog which presently challenges the team.
  • With the introduction of new email templates, streamlined processes (including “additional email elimination”), additional structure fixated on the daily goals instead of monthly goals, increased involvement and partnerships with onsite management there will be an increase of accountability. This will help the Financial Aid email team to forge better relationships with their management staff and the rest of their department. The result of this action will be a more integrated team which can effectively communicate (with internal/external customers), be able to adopt new methods to increase its problem-solving skills, and understand how achieving its goals benefits them and the rest of the organization.
  • The impact of improving this team’s customer service skills, will alleviate the students (the customers) concerns about their interactions with this specific part of the University and attending a for-profit University overall. Increasing the status of Omir University’s reputation on the administrative side amongst its student population will decrease the possibility of negative public scrutiny in various media outlets.
  • An increase of employee morale (non-tangible) and a decrease of employee turnover for this small team in the Financial Aid department are also expected to occur over time as organizational goals are met.
Anticipated Roadblocks or Difficulties
  • Segregating the team has a profound effect mentally as it does not realize the impact of its collective negative performance upon the rest of the department and organization overall. Getting the team to realize the impact of their performance upon the organization collectively and the individual is one challenge.
  • Another challenge is getting the cooperation of the entire Financial Aid department to assist with email responses (since half of the team will be in training sessions). This resistance to help the email team is a direct response to the office politics created by the competitive organizational culture. Assistance may also be needed even after the initial training sessions of the Financial Aid email team; therefore, it may be required to cross-train members of the Financial Aid call and chat teams. However, due to conflicting responsibilities and organizational culture assigning training times to properly train assigned individuals from these teams will be another (possibly major) issue entirely.
  • Having the Financial Aid email team onboard with new policies and procedures that will maximize their overall team productivity. The team is very resistant to operational changes, structure and “interference” from their management and even from the onsite directors (onsite management team).

Thursday, June 21, 2018

Organizational Clarity: Personal Development Intervention

In one of my classes we discussed practicing HPI and what possible interventions one would personally choose when it comes to the workplace. Although I do not have the text connected to the blog you can still get the idea of the discussion and follow this quick entry onto one of my required discussion posts that helped me maintain my grades ha! Please post any comments or questions to facilitate a discussion in the comments sections below.

Directions: One of the most challenging aspects of HPI practice is accurately matching interventions to problems.  Chapter 9 (page 213) contains an intervention selection tool that lists a variety of interventions.  Choose at least one intervention from the list (more if you have time) and 1) Tell us when you would use the intervention AND when you would not use this intervention, 2) Provide a link to a website that either tells us more about the particular intervention or includes an example of the intervention, 3) Review the posts of fellow students and add your thoughts.

Post:
I believe I chose the Personal Development Intervention (PDI) Feedback or 360 degree (“meetings”) feedback for the assignment in the last module, so I will go with it once more. I like the idea of not critiquing an employee’s performance but telling them what they did right and giving constructive feedback on the areas or aspects in which they can improvement upon.

I can easily see when to use the PDI: Feedback during one on one training sessions or even during annual employee performance reviews. These are times or opportunities in which management or trainers are in the position to mentor employees, build morale and encourage teamwork with the organization in a positive manner. I would use this intervention only if the organizational culture fosters a positive environment however or if it is really necessary to bring certain issues or problems to light with a measure of depth and detail.

Although this intervention can be used in a group setting, if the issues concern only one member of the team or the problem must be discussed with various details I would not use this intervention. I can easy see in a group setting that focusing in too much, on a problem may cause even further divisions and problems on a team.

This is a link to a website called “What is 360 Degree Feedback?” from Custom Insight, that explains more about the Personal Development Intervention (PDI) Feedback intervention:
http://www.custominsight.com/360-degree-feedback/what-is-360-degree-feedback.asp

Thursday, June 14, 2018

Organizational Clarity: Goals when learning about HPI


In one of my classes we were asked define our goals when it came to the class and what we should learn from HPI these are very general goals so bear with me! This is an actual entry from that class, please add any questions or points you want to share to this blog post. Please add points or possible solutions to the comments section of this blog entry.


What are your learning goals for this course? Why are they important to you?

My learning goals in this course is to understand the definition of HPI comes in the forms of questions as HPI translates differently from the academic (text) to real world application. For example, who is accountable for Intervention maintenance after the invention is completed and what factors determine the length of maintenance? This is important to me because even though an intervention is successful if the intervention is phased out after less than a year in operation what is the point of it?

I have seen this multiple times in which HPI programs have been rolled out and were implemented with success, the program got great feedback from management and the employees only to be trashed six months later. The reason I usually hear is because the program was not maintainable, whether due to budgetary concerns or staff allocation, which if proper planning was done this would not be a problem! However, it is usually because of other external factors which somehow floats the responsibility of such programs to different individuals each month like a game of spin the bottle that makes the program lose its consistency.

Another goal is to understand how Sponsors are really aligned with HPI, because accountability seems to be a problem whenever I see a workplace intervention that deals with HPI. Sponsors simply have no connection nor want to communicate or interact with anyone else involved other than say how good the intervention is going which is usually not the reality. In textbooks like the one for this class, sponsors are required to be in it for the long haul, but that is not really the case in real life applications (Van Tiem et al., 2012)! I hope that this class and the text can give me the insights to nail down disappearing sponsors that shy away from things like accountability and sustainability but look for a sizable ROI nor want to make decisions that affect change.

Oh I was sure I had to add this with the goals forum altogether but this is my questions forum post as well:

One of the burning questions that I have about HPI that I hope to be able to answer is, how to gain or maintain sustainability after a success intervention? Also another question I have, is how do you hold accountable a sponsor who is interested in a HPI one moment, then loses interests (and the HPI loses support) the next, only to be shocked when the HPI fails?

Friday, May 25, 2018

HPI: Burning Questions and Takeaways


In one of my classes that dealt with HPI there were of course a thousand questions regarding the subject however you were only allowed to pick one and discuss what we learned that semester. This is an actual entry from that class, please add any questions or points you want to share to this blog post.


Part 1: Please post your "burning question" from the Module 1 group forum and the answers you found this semester. What aspects of the question are still unclear? How might you continue to learn and gain the knowledge you need after our semester ends?
Part 2: Next tell us your key take aways from our class and how you plan to apply what you have learned.

Part 1-The burning question from the Module one group was:
“One of the burning questions that I have about HPI that I hope to be able to answer is, how to gain or maintain sustainability after a successful intervention? Also another question I have, is how do you hold accountable a sponsor who is interested in a HPI one moment, then loses interests (and the HPI loses support) the next, only to be shocked when the HPI fails?”

I have not found in-depth answers for either of these questions, that I feel are valid and very important to the success of any intervention. Most of the material covered was about what is covered during the intervention, what types of tools used, how to get the sponsor to secure resources, etc., but did not go deep enough. I think that methods like RSVP, Capacity building and implementing for sustainability are great for discussion, but only answer a change in leadership as the most logical factor for a lack of sustainability, but not organizational culture as a deterrent. Even using Mosely and Hasting’s Model stage of institutionalizing it has been my experience does not work with sponsors or CEOs that have the interest in a momentary interest in a program. Even if you use standard evaluations either formative or summative, and have positive results if the sponsor is not interested in the details or wants to jump to another program altogether (that has been my experience) maintaining sustainability or making them accountable is very hard or even impossible.

One key takeaway I took from this class is from an issue I had early in the class with the differences between the Cause Analysis and Root cause analysis. As students we have the option to refer to textbooks and other students for answers. However, in a client’s case, and the advent of google if there is confusion about the difference of the tools the client might feel more empowered to research these terms themselves in order to bridge the gaps of their understanding of the process. This in turn could cause more problems for the professional than create solutions.

In fact, I would also include the issue of many individuals in management who confuse 360-degree feedback and 360 degree appraisals into this group. Knowing this I clearly need to be wary of individuals with this type of “initiative” and have ready clear definitions on hand in case of this possible scenario to set the record straight.

The other takeaway is that these interventions can definitely be used not as tool but as retaliatory options by those in management, against employees that they feel are not meeting a certain standard. Even in cases that the employee is meeting all organizational performance standards, if this employee is not meeting a certain organizational culture these positive interventions can be abused and it is up to professional to inform the sponsors in the organization to implement consequences on these individuals to ensure the success of the program’s implementation.

Thursday, July 13, 2017

Organizational Clarity: Whether an Intervention is working

Excerpt from an Old OD posting

We know that to intervene means to change something in an organization. With change comes responsibility. How do we know for sure that our intervention will work? What do we do if it causes more harm than good?

When it comes to an intervention working I believe if some of the goals outlined in the initial planning and contract stages achieved would be an indicator. Also, I think that if the client could accomplish and grow in their roles outlined in the contract and if there is an actual change in the system and methodology of the organization to achieve increase productivity and streamline the services they provide.

If there is still resistance to the organization change set by the objectives and a consensus of what needs to be accomplished or unrealistic expectations with an illogical timeframe to complete them remain then we know that the intervention has not worked. “Clearing the weeds” or making sure that the client is fully committed to the change and all the employees are on the same page with minimal or no resistance remain on a long-term basis towards the program, could also be a benchmark that the interventions had worked.

The possible way that we are causing more harm than good is if we use the wrong intervention, based on the information the client gives us, we as consultants can just change the focus of the intervention. For example, if we are lead to believe that the issue is team based than an organization based on the client during the initial meeting, we can take the data gathered by the failed intervention to illustrate to the client the need for a directional change of the intervention. The last thing we want to do is cause more stress or further embed resistance to future interventions or lose the engagement of the members of the organization.

With the new data gathered the consultant can narrow down the focus of what is the best option(s) to solve the problem, and it can be touted to the members of the failed intervention as a step in the overall process for change management.  Meeting this hurdle with positive psychology instead of being negative towards this situation, the consultant can easily begin the buy-in process again. 
By using this as a starting point (or reason) for the need to have increased communication between members or for the client to commit to their roles, if there was a measure of resistance in these areas. The consultant can use this failure as the focal point to reenergize, refocus the members of the organization and demand resources in areas where they were previously limited.